1045 vs 4140 steel
1045 (Medium-carbon steel). The workhorse medium-carbon steel for shafts, axles and machine parts, used quenched and tempered.
4140 (Cr-Mo alloy steel). The general-purpose quenched-and-tempered alloy steel: shafts, bolts, fixtures, tooling that must not snap.
How 1045 and 4140 differ
- 1045 carries more carbon: 0.43 to 0.5% against 0.38 to 0.43% in 4140.
- 4140 is alloyed with chromium (0.8 to 1.1%), which 1045 does not have in any real amount.
- 4140 is austenitized hotter: 845 to 870 °C (1555 to 1600 °F) against 815 to 845 °C (1500 to 1555 °F) for 1045.
- The quench differs. 1045: water or brine, oil for thin sections. 4140: oil.
Side by side
| 1045 | 4140 | |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Medium-carbon steel | Cr-Mo alloy steel |
| Carbon (C), wt % | 0.43 to 0.5 | 0.38 to 0.43 |
| Manganese (Mn), wt % | 0.6 to 0.9 | 0.75 to 1 |
| Silicon (Si), wt % | none listed | 0.15 to 0.35 |
| Chromium (Cr), wt % | none listed | 0.8 to 1.1 |
| Molybdenum (Mo), wt % | none listed | 0.15 to 0.25 |
| Austenitize | 815 to 845 °C (1500 to 1555 °F) | 845 to 870 °C (1555 to 1600 °F) |
| Quench | Water or brine, oil for thin sections | Oil |
| Temper | 315 to 595 °C (600 to 1105 °F) | 400 to 650 °C (750 to 1200 °F) |
| Typical hardness | About 55 HRC as quenched at the surface, 20 to 30 HRC after machinery tempers | About 54 to 59 HRC as quenched, 28 to 36 HRC after machinery tempers |
| Ac1 (lower critical temperature) | about 715 °C (1319 °F) | about 737 °C (1359 °F) |
| Ac3 (upper critical temperature) | about 772 °C (1421 °F) | about 798 °C (1469 °F) |
| Ms (martensite start) | about 320 °C (607 °F) | about 328 °C (623 °F) |
Ac1, Ac3 and Ms are estimates from the Andrews (1965) correlations at mid-range composition. They are withheld where a steel falls outside the low-alloy range those correlations cover, and Ac3 is withheld for steels above about 0.8% carbon. Typical published practice for guidance. Section size, prior condition, furnace accuracy and soak time all shift the right numbers. Verify against your steel supplier's datasheet before hardening anything that matters.
Heat treating each one
1045
Shallow hardening: heavy sections harden at the skin only. Water quenching risks distortion and cracks on sharp corners, so radius and pre-machine generously.
4140
Deep hardening and predictable. Many shops avoid tempering between about 260 and 370 C, where tempered martensite embrittlement costs toughness without buying hardness.
Questions
- What is the difference between 1045 and 4140 steel?
- 1045 carries more carbon: 0.43 to 0.5% against 0.38 to 0.43% in 4140. 4140 is alloyed with chromium (0.8 to 1.1%), which 1045 does not have in any real amount.
- Is 1045 or 4140 harder after heat treatment?
- Typical hardness for 1045: about 55 HRC as quenched at the surface, 20 to 30 HRC after machinery tempers. For 4140: about 54 to 59 HRC as quenched, 28 to 36 HRC after machinery tempers. The result depends on the temper you choose.
- Can I heat treat 1045 and 4140 the same way?
- No, each has its own recipe. 1045: austenitize at 815 to 845 °C, quench in water or brine, oil for thin sections, temper at 315 to 595 °C. 4140: austenitize at 845 to 870 °C, quench in oil, temper at 400 to 650 °C.
Heat treatment numbers for your own steel, with sources.
Heat treatment numbers for common steels, each traced to its source paper. About HeatTreat