5160 vs 6150 steel
5160 (Cr spring steel). Leaf-spring steel and the sword maker's friend. Outstanding toughness with honest hardness.
6150 (Cr-V spring steel). Vanadium spring steel for valve springs, torsion bars and tough tooling. Fine grained by design.
How 5160 and 6150 differ
- 5160 carries more carbon: 0.56 to 0.64% against 0.48 to 0.53% in 6150.
- 6150 is austenitized hotter: 845 to 885 °C (1555 to 1625 °F) against 815 to 845 °C (1500 to 1555 °F) for 5160.
- Both are quenched the same way: oil.
Side by side
| 5160 | 6150 | |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Cr spring steel | Cr-V spring steel |
| Carbon (C), wt % | 0.56 to 0.64 | 0.48 to 0.53 |
| Manganese (Mn), wt % | 0.75 to 1 | 0.7 to 0.9 |
| Silicon (Si), wt % | 0.15 to 0.35 | 0.15 to 0.35 |
| Chromium (Cr), wt % | 0.7 to 0.9 | 0.8 to 1.1 |
| Vanadium (V), wt % | none listed | 0.15 to 0.25 |
| Austenitize | 815 to 845 °C (1500 to 1555 °F) | 845 to 885 °C (1555 to 1625 °F) |
| Quench | Oil | Oil |
| Temper | 190 to 480 °C (375 to 895 °F) | 400 to 540 °C (750 to 1005 °F) |
| Typical hardness | 57 to 59 HRC at a 200 C temper for blades, 44 to 48 HRC at spring tempers | 42 to 48 HRC at spring tempers |
| Ac1 (lower critical temperature) | about 734 °C (1354 °F) | about 738 °C (1360 °F) |
| Ac3 (upper critical temperature) | about 764 °C (1407 °F) | about 798 °C (1468 °F) |
| Ms (martensite start) | about 249 °C (480 °F) | about 290 °C (553 °F) |
Ac1, Ac3 and Ms are estimates from the Andrews (1965) correlations at mid-range composition. They are withheld where a steel falls outside the low-alloy range those correlations cover, and Ac3 is withheld for steels above about 0.8% carbon. Typical published practice for guidance. Section size, prior condition, furnace accuracy and soak time all shift the right numbers. Verify against your steel supplier's datasheet before hardening anything that matters.
Heat treating each one
5160
The chromium buys hardenability, so ordinary oil works even on thick blades. For springs temper at 370 to 480 C.
6150
The vanadium spec is a 0.15 minimum; the range shown is typical. Vanadium carbides pin grain growth, so it tolerates the hotter end of the austenitizing window.
Questions
- What is the difference between 5160 and 6150 steel?
- 5160 carries more carbon: 0.56 to 0.64% against 0.48 to 0.53% in 6150. 6150 is austenitized hotter: 845 to 885 °C (1555 to 1625 °F) against 815 to 845 °C (1500 to 1555 °F) for 5160.
- Is 5160 or 6150 harder after heat treatment?
- Typical hardness for 5160: 57 to 59 HRC at a 200 C temper for blades, 44 to 48 HRC at spring tempers. For 6150: 42 to 48 HRC at spring tempers. The result depends on the temper you choose.
- Can I heat treat 5160 and 6150 the same way?
- No, each has its own recipe. 5160: austenitize at 815 to 845 °C, quench in oil, temper at 190 to 480 °C. 6150: austenitize at 845 to 885 °C, quench in oil, temper at 400 to 540 °C.
Heat treatment numbers for your own steel, with sources.
Heat treatment numbers for common steels, each traced to its source paper. About HeatTreat