Can silicon reduce Al₂O₃?
No, not at standard conditions. Al₂O₃ is the more stable oxide at every temperature the data cover, 298 K (25 °C) to 1996 K (1723 °C).
The reaction is 3 Si + 2 Al₂O₃ → 3 SiO₂ + 4 Al, producing aluminium. The answer comes from comparing two Ellingham lines computed from NIST data: Si + O₂ → SiO₂ and 4/3 Al + O₂ → 2/3 Al₂O₃.
Whichever line is lower at a given temperature belongs to the more stable oxide. Silicon can take the oxygen from Al₂O₃ wherever the SiO₂ line is below the Al₂O₃ line. The two do not cross in the range the data cover.
ΔG° of 3 Si + 2 Al₂O₃ → 3 SiO₂ + 4 Al
| T (K) | T (°C) | SiO₂ line (kJ/mol O₂) | Al₂O₃ line (kJ/mol O₂) | ΔG° of reduction (kJ/mol O₂) | Favoured? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 400 | 127 | -837.8 | -1033.5 | 195.7 | No |
| 600 | 327 | -801.4 | -991.5 | 190.2 | No |
| 800 | 527 | -765.5 | -950.0 | 184.5 | No |
| 1000 | 727 | -730.3 | -907.6 | 177.4 | No |
| 1200 | 927 | -695.4 | -863.5 | 168.1 | No |
| 1400 | 1127 | -660.9 | -819.6 | 158.7 | No |
| 1600 | 1327 | -626.6 | -776.0 | 149.4 | No |
| 1800 | 1527 | -589.1 | -732.6 | 143.5 | No |
ΔG° of reduction is the SiO₂ line minus the Al₂O₃ line, per mole of O₂ moved. Negative means the reduction is favoured with every substance in its standard state: pure solids and liquids, gases at 1 bar.
What this comparison leaves out
- It is thermodynamics only. A favoured reaction can still be far too slow to use at low temperature.
- It compares the two oxide lines and nothing else. Carbides, suboxides, mixed oxides, alloys and volatile species such as metal vapour are not included, and they decide many real processes.
- It assumes standard states. Lower gas pressures, dissolved metal or slag chemistry all move the balance.
- It covers only the temperatures the NIST data are tabulated for. Nothing is extrapolated.
Questions
- Can silicon reduce Al₂O₃?
- No, not at standard conditions. Al₂O₃ is the more stable oxide at every temperature the data cover, 298 K (25 °C) to 1996 K (1723 °C).
- What is the reaction when silicon reduces Al₂O₃?
- 3 Si + 2 Al₂O₃ → 3 SiO₂ + 4 Al. It is the Si + O₂ → SiO₂ reaction running forwards while 4/3 Al + O₂ → 2/3 Al₂O₃ runs backwards.
- What is ΔG° for reducing Al₂O₃ with silicon at 927 °C?
- At 1200 K (927 °C) it is 168.1 kJ per mole of O₂ moved, so the reduction is not favoured at standard conditions.
Pick any two lines and read the crossover.
An interactive Ellingham diagram, computed live from NIST data. About Ellingham